Regrouping · Iteration 01

Split a collision by remembering the lost choice

Original discussion: 25 October 2026; exact message times were not recorded. This summary was reconstructed .

We reviewed why Argon's finite apex assignments and passing checks did not establish the universal Phase 2 bijection. Christopher then proposed studying the collision fibers directly and using extra dimensions to separate their inputs.

What we clarified

A counting identity is not an object-by-object translator

The KR1 counting identity has reported proofs, including Mizuno's Theorem 1.1. Our goal is an explicit reversible construction between the original partition families. The unresolved step in our chosen factorization is the middle bridge:

B ↔ U ↔ C ↔ A   ·   U ↔ C remains incomplete

Here U is the weighted-column model and C consists of sectors (a,b,μ,ν), with weight a² + 3ab + 3b² + Σμ + 3Σν. A finite matching table or arithmetic weight identity does not supply the full forward and inverse algorithms.

A solved restricted family, drawn concretely

Spacing data mu equals 1,4,6 gives weight20 and weighted columns10,8,1,1.
For a=3,b=0, the reviewed partial map handles every spacing triple. The μ diagram records increments, not the full gap-condition partition. Green-cell numbers are weights; their column totals give U.

This is a restricted infinite result, not a full KR1 bijection. Its significance and novelty have not been established by comparison with the closest literature.

Why a family needs more than a finite list

Historical figure: this y=2 band was open at the initial review. It was subsequently covered by the partial constructions below; the title in the original image describes that earlier checkpoint.

Three members of the historical a4,b0 family mu=(x,x,x+2,x+2), at x0,1,2.
The common width x survives the proposed stripping operations. Assigning a few apexes cannot determine the rule for all x or its inverse. This motivated looking for information that a new direction could retain.
Christopher Yamba's intuition

Replace one ambiguous image with distinguishable arrangements

“What if we consider the U as an ambiguous image that needs to be split into two distinct images U1 and U2.”

Christopher proposed starting with T1 and T2 that collapse to the same U, arranging the actual numbered squares differently in additional dimensions, and generalizing to every finite fiber size. Ten colliding inputs could use ten extra directions. Existence of one suitable procedure comes before optimizing dimension.

Two tableaux differing by the positions of4 and5 have the same sorted hook image, which loses their starting arrangement.
The ordinary-tableau illustration that prompted the idea. A reverse move must recover which input produced the hook. This is a separate cancellation example; its label-order statistic must not be confused with KR1 partition weight.

The guiding question was: what would the extra direction remember (a cut location, overlap, ordering or carry), and how would the final object let us undo it?

First constructions motivated by that idea

Two ordinary tableaux take different shapes to retain the lost choice; below are KR1 weight20 and weight22 examples from new partial families.
Above: shape can retain the lost choice in this ordinary example. Below: explicit KR1 examples in the newly covered (4,0) slabs. The y=2,3,4 claims have ordinary proofs with distinct review, conditional on the retained baseline. They do not settle the remaining sectors.

These were related shape-routing and column-encoding explorations. They did not implement Christopher's complete algorithm of introducing a fresh axis for each placement.

Handoff and what followed

Try literal placements; record the inverse and first failure

The independent Claude Code handoff asked for reversible permutations of occupied and empty positions in a discrete multidimensional space, a placement ledger, and patterns that might generalize. Worktrees were kept separate. Its output then informed the joint core attempt summarized in iteration 02.

Still open: a general selected family of higher-dimensional arrangements and an intrinsic, weight-preserving correspondence with the original targets.